A major up-dating is set for October 4 at the London home of the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales – its 2019 Audit Conference, “Reflect, Reform, Refocus.” Proceedings will be reported in the next issue of its magazine Audit & Beyond – but live attendance on Friday will be worth it.
The context is volatile and challenging. Relevant current events include:
- The September 23 collapse of venerable travel operator Thomas Cook, this time with a gloss on the expected query -- “Where was EY?” -- that features the absence of a “going concern” qualification in its 2017 and 2018 opinions.
- The on-going noncompliance of Mike Ashley’s Sports Direct with the requirement, unfulfilled since its September 8 Annual General Meeting, that the company find an auditor willing to succeed Grant Thornton.
- And the persistent silence of the Competition & Markets Authority, following its April 18 report, which proposed that most of the FTSE 350 should be obliged to engage a second audit firm, selected from among the so-called “challengers.”
These items of immediate attention are piled on those of recent months, in addition to the CMA’s report – the report by Sir John Kingman on December 18, 2018, which set up the on-going process of rehabilitating the Financial Reporting Council into a new Audit, Reporting and Governance Authority, and the April 2, 2019, report of the Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy committee of Parliament with its calls for yet more aggressive steps to force a reduction in the near-total large company audit dominance of the Big Four, break up the Big Four, or hobble the scope and skills of their audit practices.
The morning keynote speaker at the ICAEW conference will be Sir Donald Brydon, expected to bring the world up-to-date – albeit with sensitivity and due regard for protocols and discretion – on the state of his mission, launched in December 2018 by the Business Secretary, to inquire and report on “the Quality and Effectiveness of Audit.”
Views on the broad range of concerns will be offered by speakers from practitioners, the standard-setters, and the regulators – see its programme.
I will be there, with a few words to offer. No spoiler alerts are needed – the grounds and reasons for my skepticism about the mooted “reforms” are laid out in my book of this May, short but detailed -- “DOA: Can Big Audit Survive the UK Regulators?”
For those unable to be in Chartered Accountants’ Hall on the 4th, my perspectives on the issues derive in good part from this single graphic, showing the global accounting networks with 2018 revenue greater than $ 500 million.
Anyone paying attention to the implications of this array, and still clinging to the belief that either joint audits or forced market share re-allocation can be achieved, is invited to bring forth the arguments. Presentation space will be offered here, free and in full – fairly warned that the section will be labeled “Fiction and Fantasy.”
Thanks for joining this dialog. Please share with friends and colleagues. Comments and feedback are invited and welcome, and subscription sign-up is easy and free, both at the Main page.